Sergey Nivens - Fotolia

Evaluate Weigh the pros and cons of technologies, products and projects you are considering.

Node.js vs. .NET Core: 3 key considerations

Both open source development runtimes offer advantages for web and mobile builds, so developers should choose based on performance, containers and scaling as well as peer support.

Node.js and .NET Core are two well-known, open source development environments that provide speed, power, concurrency and scalability to the development process. Each offers strengths and limitations, and each improves with every new release. But for many developers, the decision of Node.js vs. .NET Core comes down to a given project's needs.

For example, due to its origin as an open system, Node.js is thought to offer better diversity and more free tools, while .NET Core is perceived to be constrained by its association with Microsoft. However, .NET Core offers the benefits of a well-established, mature ecosystem that boasts better CPU processing and IDE support than Node.js.

For next-generation website and mobile application builds, Node.js and .NET Core each provide an impressive number of programming features to meet performance demands. Of course, both frameworks have a learning curve, yet each offers critical advantages to achieving the speed, power and scalability demanded by distributed workloads. Compare Node.js and .NET Core, and consider the pros and cons for developers in your organization.

Node.js basics

Introduced in 2009, Node.js was designed for Linux and Apple's MacOS as a scalable alternative to the Apache HTTP Server. A native Windows version came out in 2011. Since Node.js is based in JavaScript, developers can use it to write application front ends and back ends. Developers also can use any language that compiles to JavaScript, such as Scala, ClojureScript and CoffeeScript.

Node.js provides prewritten code in the form of modules that reside within packages. These modules function like JavaScript libraries to enable quick and efficient programming. The Node.js repository, NPM, contains almost half a million packages. An automatic lock-file mechanism in NPM simplifies and secures new dependencies within projects.

Inside .NET Core

In contrast to Node.js, .NET Core is based on the object-oriented programming language C#. Released in 2016, this cross-platform, cloud-friendly framework is used for .NET projects. Developers also have the ability to use diverse languages with the overall .NET framework, including VB.NET, C++, and F#.

Graph of top open source development environments

The .NET offering includes class libraries of prewritten code that support both simple and complex data structures. It also has specific libraries for security, encryption and database access. There are large predefined class libraries for things such as graphics rendering, database interactions and XML manipulations.

.NET Core uses NuGet as a package management tool for version tracking and updates within dynamic link libraries (DLL). NuGet enables programmers to save multiple versions of a DLL and then apply those packages as needed. NuGet takes care of dependency chains and versioning conflicts at installation, which can simplify the process to find, install, update and uninstall packages for applications.

The Microsoft Visual Studio IDE is a key .NET component. It eases development by integrating build, debugging and publishing processes across multiple platforms and devices. Visual Studio is a single IDE for all .NET applications.

Asynchronous processes in Node.js vs. .NET Core

Asynchronous processes enable programs to get more done at once.

Node.js uses non-blocking methods to serve I/O requests and achieve low latency and high throughput. For example, the single-threaded event loop allows Node.js to deal with incoming requests while it's waiting for other tasks to finish. This callback function can either respond to requests with non-blocking I/O calls, or allow blocking for processes like load balancing.

Node.js is also suited to multiple I/O operations and real-time requests. The event loop enables the asynchronous aspect of Node.js, so the framework handles more connections than most competing architectures. However, Node.js is less effective than other options like .NET Core for CPU-heavy software. For example, the long-running calculations found in machine learning software can block incoming requests and cause performance deficits.

By comparison, .NET Core has an asynchronous/await pattern, as well as garbage collection, automatic memory management and shared binaries across multiple platforms. Threads in .NET Core are a way to schedule work to process simultaneously. The Task Parallel Library lives on top of the thread model, to simplify task scheduling and management.

Similar container capabilities

Many development organizations are working with containers, or have containerization on their roadmaps, so they should evaluate Node.js and .NET Core in this area. Both options offer a modular framework with diverse container capabilities.

By using containers in Node.js, developers can quickly reproduce build components and scale fast. Node.js deploys horizontal scaling to handle sizable request loads, which is part of its capabilities for rapid development and microservices architectures. Since containerized Node.js applications can scale fast at the process level, developers can independently ramp up and shrink down applications as necessary depending on the requirements of specific workloads.

Similar to Node.js, .NET Core helps developers build and deploy web-based, mobile server or desktop workloads. In .NET Core, the upgraded Microsoft Nano Server container OS provides developers with a small, customizable runtime, geared toward fast-deploying containers, whether in Windows or container-optimized Linux distributions.

Comparative user communities

Both Node.js and .NET Core are open source frameworks with dedicated, vibrant user communities.

In .NET Core forums, users discuss a wide array of problems and share code for fixes. This community interaction is a sharp contrast to the long lag times between Microsoft releases and improvements that were commonplace in the past.

The Node.js community is steadily growing and equally active, with consistently high-quality packages. In addition to several community forums, the support includes learning resources and diverse international outreach.

Dig Deeper on Application programming languages and coding